Math with Confidence vs Apologia Math Choosing the Right Homeschool CurriculumChoosing the right math curriculum is one of the most important decisions for homeschool parents. With so many programs available, two that frequently stand out are Math with Confidence and Apologia Math. Each offers a unique approach, tone, and structure for teaching mathematics at home. This topic compares the two to help you decide which is best suited for your child’s learning style and your teaching goals.
Overview of Math with Confidence
Math with Confidence, created by Kate Snow, is a relatively new but increasingly popular math curriculum for early elementary grades. The series is designed to be engaging, hands-on, and developmentally appropriate. It focuses on building a strong foundation in number sense, arithmetic, and math reasoning through daily, short lessons and playful activities.
Key Features
-
Targeted for Kindergarten through Grade 6
-
Short and focused daily lessons
-
Emphasis on mastery and confidence-building
-
Includes games, review, and real-life applications
-
Requires minimal preparation time
Overview of Apologia Math
Apologia Math, developed by the Apologia educational group, is known for its strong Christian worldview and rigorous academic standards. It integrates math instruction with biblical principles, making it appealing to families who want a faith-based curriculum.
Key Features
-
Covers elementary through middle school
-
Spiral learning approach with review built in
-
Incorporates stories and real-life scenarios
-
Christian worldview integrated into lessons
-
Colorful student texts with step-by-step instructions
Teaching Approach
Math with Confidence
This curriculum uses a mastery-based approach, meaning each concept is taught thoroughly before moving on. It encourages consistent review, but without overwhelming the student. Lessons follow a predictable routine warm-up, teaching, hands-on activity, and review.
Teachers are provided with a full script and clear guidance, making it ideal for parents without a strong math background. Activities often include household objects, simple games, and short worksheets.
Apologia Math
Apologia takes a spiral approach, introducing concepts and then revisiting them throughout the year. This method supports long-term retention and builds connections between topics. Lessons are more text-heavy, with stories, questions, and step-by-step explanations.
There is a strong narrative element to Apologia Math, which helps some children relate better to math concepts. However, it may require more time and parental involvement per lesson.
Ease of Use
Math with Confidence
-
Parent-friendly with scripted lessons
-
Low prep, using common household materials
-
Short lessons (15-20 minutes) fit well into busy schedules
-
Visual aids are simple and easy to replicate
Apologia Math
-
More structured and detailed lessons
-
Requires some parent reading and preparation
-
Visual aids are provided in the student text
-
May take 30-45 minutes per lesson depending on pace
Religious Content
Math with Confidence
This program is secular, meaning it does not include any religious or faith-based content. It is suitable for families from any background or belief system and focuses entirely on academic development.
Apologia Math
As a Christian curriculum, Apologia weaves in Bible verses, faith-based reflection questions, and Christian themes. This makes it appealing to families who want to incorporate faith into all areas of study.
Flexibility and Adaptability
Math with Confidence
Because of its structure and simplicity, Math with Confidence is very adaptable. Parents can easily skip or repeat lessons, modify activities for different skill levels, or add supplementary practice if needed.
Apologia Math
Apologia Math follows a more formal structure. While adaptable to some degree, it works best when followed in sequence. The spiral design assumes continual review, so skipping too many lessons may cause gaps.
Cost Comparison
-
Math with Confidence tends to be more budget-friendly. The teacher’s guide and student workbook are sold separately but are relatively affordable.
-
Apologia Math is slightly more expensive due to its full-color materials and hardcover books. However, it includes built-in review and stories, which reduce the need for extra supplements.
Student Engagement
Math with Confidence
Young learners often enjoy the interactive, hands-on components. Because lessons are short and playful, many children stay engaged and look forward to math time.
Apologia Math
Students who enjoy reading, stories, and structure may find Apologia more engaging. The Christian content may also inspire deeper reflection for those in faith-based families. However, some younger children may find the format less playful and more formal.
Ideal Users
Math with Confidence is best for
-
Parents new to homeschooling
-
Children who need hands-on activities
-
Families looking for a secular curriculum
-
Learners who do better with short, focused lessons
Apologia Math is best for
-
Families seeking Christian-based education
-
Children who enjoy stories and structured explanations
-
Parents comfortable with reading and guiding lessons
-
Homeschoolers wanting a complete math and values package
Pros and Cons at a Glance
| Curriculum | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Math with Confidence | Easy to use, engaging, short lessons | Limited to early grades so far |
| Apologia Math | Faith-based, spiral learning, detailed | Longer lessons, more reading |
Choosing between Math with Confidence and Apologia Math depends largely on your family’s educational goals, values, and teaching preferences. If you’re looking for a light, activity-based, secular curriculum, Math with Confidence is an excellent option. If you prefer a more structured and faith-integrated approach, Apologia Math might be the better fit.
Both curricula are thoughtfully designed and can serve as effective tools for building strong math skills. The key is finding the one that aligns best with your child’s learning style and your vision for homeschooling success.