The Dartmoor mission in Hitman 3, titled ‘Death in the Family,’ presents a unique murder mystery twist that blends stealth gameplay with detective work. One of the intriguing objectives in this mission involves accusing the correct suspect in the death of Zachary Carlisle. Among the suspects is Emma Carlisle, and players often want to know how to accuse Emma and gather all the clues required to support the accusation. To accuse Emma successfully, Agent 47 must investigate thoroughly, collect specific pieces of evidence, and confront the right person with the findings. The process is methodical, immersive, and very different from traditional assassinations in the game.
Understanding the Dartmoor Murder Mystery
The Setting and Objective
The mission takes place in a massive English manor known as Thornbridge Manor. Agent 47 is disguised as a private detective, hired by Alexa Carlisle to solve the apparent suicide of her brother, Zachary. However, the situation quickly unfolds into a deeper mystery, revealing that Zachary may have been murdered, and multiple family members have motives.
While you can complete the mission without solving the mystery, many players choose to dive into the detective path to experience the game’s unique narrative route. Accusing the correct suspect is optional but highly rewarding, especially if you want to accuse Emma Carlisle based on evidence you gather.
Steps to Accuse Emma in Hitman 3
Step 1: Start the Investigation
When you first arrive at Thornbridge Manor, head to the front door and speak with the butler. Let him know you’re the detective, and you’ll be granted entry into the investigation. This will start the ‘Means, Motive, and Opportunity’ storyline, which is essential for accusing Emma.
Step 2: Investigate Zachary’s Bedroom
Begin by heading upstairs to Zachary’s bedroom. This is where the supposed suicide took place. In the room, investigate the following clues:
- The suicide note on the table near the bed.
- The whiskey glass and bottle on the side table.
- The laptop with Zachary’s journal entry.
Scan these items using your camera. You’ll learn that Zachary suspected he was going to be murdered and had information about family secrets.
Step 3: Examine the Body
Scan Zachary’s body to find signs of poisoning. Use your camera to analyze him. The conclusion is that he was poisoned, which rules out suicide. This begins pointing toward a deliberate act by someone in the house.
Step 4: Interrogate the Family Members
Next, you’ll have the opportunity to question various members of the Carlisle family. Each one provides different alibis and statements. Pay particular attention when questioning Emma Carlisle. Ask about her movements and interactions with Zachary. Some of her answers may feel suspicious or evasive.
Step 5: Find the Greenhouse Key
The key to accusing Emma lies in the greenhouse. The door to the greenhouse is locked, so your next step is to find the key. There are two ways to get access:
- Find the Greenhouse Key Chain in Emma and Gregory’s Room.
- Pick the lock using a lockpick if you have one.
Emma and Gregory’s bedroom is upstairs. Search their room thoroughly to find the key chain. There are also important clues in their room like a walking cane and a letter from Emma’s mother.
Step 6: Investigate the Greenhouse
Once inside the greenhouse, use your camera to scan the items. There you’ll find several pieces of damning evidence:
- A book about poisonous plants.
- A distillation kit used for extracting poison.
- Traces of lethal poison that match Zachary’s cause of death.
This strongly indicates that someone was actively producing poison there, and the evidence begins to point clearly toward Emma.
Step 7: Final Clue The Footprints
Before you make your accusation, investigate the footprints leading from the house to the greenhouse. Use your camera to analyze them. These muddy footprints suggest someone had recently visited the greenhouse, and their size indicates a female figure. This final clue helps reinforce your case against Emma Carlisle.
Confronting Mr. Fernsby
Present Your Evidence
Once you’ve gathered all the required clues, return to Mr. Fernsby, the butler. He will ask for your findings. You’ll have the option to present your conclusion and accuse one of the suspects. To accuse Emma Carlisle, choose her name and back it up with the clues you’ve discovered.
Outcomes of the Accusation
If you successfully accuse Emma, Mr. Fernsby will handle the rest and inform Alexa Carlisle. As a reward for solving the mystery correctly, Alexa will hand over the case file that Agent 47 needs to complete the main mission. This path avoids any violence or confrontation and earns you a clean Silent Assassin rating if you proceed carefully.
Why Accuse Emma Carlisle?
Emma’s Motive and Background
Emma Carlisle has a strong motive. Through notes and documents, you’ll learn that Emma believes she is the rightful heir to the Carlisle estate. Her mother had a long-running rivalry with Alexa, and Emma resents being pushed aside. Her background in chemistry and access to the greenhouse materials make her the most likely suspect.
Building a Solid Case
What makes accusing Emma satisfying is how it fits together through observation, deduction, and environmental storytelling. The items in the greenhouse, her missing alibi gaps, and her motive form a narrative that aligns perfectly with a deliberate act of murder. It’s a well-crafted subplot in Hitman 3 and rewards players who pay close attention to detail.
Tips for New Players
- Use your camera frequently to analyze objects. Many clues won’t register unless scanned.
- Explore each room thoroughly, including side tables, bookshelves, and wardrobes.
- Take your time during interrogations. Some responses can lead to hidden clues or new dialogue options.
- If you fail or miss evidence, restart the mission with your knowledge. The early steps go quicker once you know the layout.
Accusing Emma Carlisle in Hitman 3 is a rewarding experience that adds a detective flavor to the traditional gameplay. To succeed, you must collect a series of clues across the manor, including investigating Zachary’s room, searching the greenhouse, and interrogating the suspects. The puzzle comes together piece by piece, and the outcome lets you complete the mission without resorting to violence. Whether you’re chasing a Silent Assassin rank or simply enjoy narrative exploration, accusing Emma offers one of the most satisfying paths in the Dartmoor mission. Use logic, observe carefully, and follow the evidence justice awaits in Thornbridge Manor.